John W. Wenzel, wenzel.12@osu.edu, Ohio State University, Department of Entomology, 1315 Kinnear Road, Columbus, OH
The rise of probablistic statistical analysis has obscured the
importance of phylogenetic studies in testing evolutionary
theories. Strict scientific method requires hypothesis testing in a narrow
framework, accepting or rejecting a null hypothesis directly. Scientific
theories are much larger philosophical constructs than hypotheses, they
apply sometimes and not others, or to varying degrees in various
situations. As such, they do not lend themselves to the methods of
hypothesis testing in the common sense. Appropriate tests of theories are
seen more through phylogenetic analysis than through simple tests of a null
hypothesis. Modern methods permit phylogenetic studies to return to the
forefront of evolutionary theory.
Keywords: Scientific method, Systematics