In 2004, 81% said that, once a field is treated with an insecticide, soybean aphids could repopulate and cause yield damage in the same year. In 2004, 75% said aphids damaged their soybeans by sucking sap compared to 72% in Michigan and 75% in Minnesota in 2005. In 2004, 77% of the farmers completing the survey said the frequency with which aphids should be treated for profitable control depends on aphid counts, weather conditions, and plant stage compared to 79% in Michigan and 77% in Minnesota in 2005. In 2004, 15% believed that aphids inflict the most yield damage from early vegetative (V5) through early flowering and pod set (R3, maybe R4) compared to 21% in Michigan and 26% in Minnesota in 2005. In 2004, 66% of the farmers completing the survey considered the lowest average aphid density for profitable insecticide spraying to be 250 aphids per plant compared to 75% in Michigan and 68% in Minnesota in 2005.
Over all three states, 84% of the farmers in 2004 said the most important information for making a decision to treat soybean aphids was scouting reports; 54% said plant growth stage was very important in their decision. In 2005, 87% in Michigan and 94% in Minnesota said scouting reports were the very important; 75% in Michigan and 84% in Minnesota said plant growth stage was very important.